The Real Origin of Superman

How a Megalomaniacal Villain Evolved into the Man of Steel

© Michael Jung

Nov 24, 2008
Superman: Fleisher Cartoon, Public Domain
For decades, Superman set the standard for modern superheroes. So it may come as a shock to learn that his superhero creators originally meant for him to be a villain.

Editor's Choice

In 1933, high school students Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster were hard at work promoting their fanzine Science Fiction: The Advance Guard of Future Civilization. In the third issue (dated January 1933), Siegel wrote a story entitled “The Reign of the Super-Man.” Shuster’s illustration showed the giant head of a bald villain resembling Lex Luthor looming over a city of skyscrapers.

The Superman in this story is Bill Dunn, a Depression-era vagrant who ingests a serum created by Professor Smalley (the bald villain in Shuster’s illustration). The serum gives Dunn the ability to read and control minds; see the future; and absorb “all the knowledge that exists in the universe.” He kills Smalley and tries to dominate the world – but his superpowers prove temporary and he becomes a vagrant again.

Critics find this Superman resembles the Nazi Übermensch. Originally an idea of German philosopher Frederich Nietzsche, the Übermensch is a human with a mind so advanced he can shape his own destiny without the need for God. Although Nietzsche stressed an Übermensch would not rule others, Adolf Hitler later distorted this idea for his Aryan master race.

Notably, neither Siegel nor Shuster – both sons of Jewish immigrants – stated why they named their character “Superman.” In his book Superman: The Complete History, Les Daniels suggests Siegel got the name from other science fiction writers.

The Forgotten Superman

Shortly after “Reign of the Super-Man” was published, Siegel decided a heroic version of Superman might be popular with a comic book publisher. Together, Siegel and Shuster created The Superman, a black-and-white comic book. According to Daniels, while this Superman did not have powers or a costume, he was now a crime fighter instead of a villain.

Unfortunately, the Chicago comic book publisher they created the book for rejected the comic book and went out of business. Years later, this new Superman would be recycled into Siegel and Shuster’s character Slam Bradley, a private detective who appeared in Detective Comics #1.

A New Superman

Siegel then decided to develop a new Superman newspaper comic. According to Gerard Jones' book Men of Tomorrow (2004), since Shuster was growing disillusioned with the character, Siegel created different versions of the new Superman newspaper comic with other artists, including cartoonist Russell Keaton. However, none of these collaborations worked out.

Eventually, Siegel and Shuster worked on Superman again, this time re-inventing him as an alien from outer space with superpowers. Siegel gave this Superman a dual identity as Clark Kent (named after actor Clark Gable) and created Lois Lane, who represented all the girls in school who ignored him.

Shuster worked off Siegel’s ideas, developing Superman’s familiar superhero costume and adding a cape to emphasize movement. Since this Superman was still intended for a newspaper comic, Shuster colored the superhero costume with primary colors that would look good in the Sunday comics.

Although the classic Superman elements were now in place, editors still weren’t interested. For four years, every newspaper syndicate turned Superman down.

Action Comics Superman

Then in 1938, DC Comics called the McClure Syndicate searching for material for DC’s new book Action Comics. The syndicate sent samples of Siegel and Shuster’s Superman newspaper comic to the comic book publisher, which were bought by editor Vin Sullivan.

Because of deadlines, the initial Superman comic books were created by cutting and pasting strips from the Superman newspaper comic onto the book’s pages, resulting in a crude construction. But that didn’t matter – by its seventh issue Action Comics sold more than half a million copies a month. When surveys indicated that most fans bought the book for its Superman superhero stories, Superman was given his own comic book. Soon, Superman was inspiring other superhero stories and characters, from Batman to the Flash to Green Lantern.

Since his turbulent beginnings, Superman has remained one of popular culture’s most enduring icons. Yet none of this would have been possible had Siegel and Shuster not persisted in promoting their constantly evolving character.

Sources:

Daniels, Les. DC Comics: Sixty Years of the World’s Favorite Comic Book Heroes. NY: Little, Brown and Company, 1995.

Daniels, Les. Superman: The Complete History. CA: Chronicle Books, 2004.

Jones, Gerard. Men of Tomorrow: Geeks, Gangsters, and the Birth of the Comic Book. NY: Basic Books, 2004.

Also See:

The Real Origin of Batman

The Real Origin of Iron Man


The copyright of the article The Real Origin of Superman in Graphic Novels/Comics is owned by Michael Jung. Permission to republish The Real Origin of Superman in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.


Superman: Fleisher Cartoon, Public Domain
       


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo

Comments
Nov 24, 2008 5:11 PM
Guest :
Never heard of "The Forgotten Superman" version, the one you say evolved into Slam Bradley. Where else can I find info on this character? (What sources did you use?)
Nov 24, 2008 9:14 PM
Michael Jung :
Thanks for commenting!

Both of the books listed under "References" in my article have information on the second Superman. While Joe Shuster destroyed all the artwork associated with this comic, a cover did survive and is shown on page 21 of "DC Comics: Sixty Years of the World’s Favorite Comic Book Heroes".
Nov 25, 2008 2:47 AM
Guest :
actually the alien origin came later in the Seigel-Keaton strips from 34 Here Superman was from earth's far future, and it was from earth's destruction the infant Superman escapes in a time machine built by his father.
This work up also included a "Smallville"-esque superman as a boy coming to terms with his powers back story.

The key element common to the heroic-Superman are his highly evolved physiology. This is the difference between Bill Dunn and Clark Kent they are chalk and cheese otherwise, they both share a titular name, but otherwise are diametrically opposite.

Bill Dunn is more like Wylie's Gladiator 1930 and the later Captain America, ie an augmented human being.

Superman owes more to Burroughs Tarzan and John Carter Warlord of Mars

On the one hand you've the more evolved human among the apes, and on the other the man able to be super on account of the lighter gravity of the smaller planet. Roll those together, and use the Superman title and you get comic book character.
3 Comments